Columbia Men's Newton Ridge Plus II Suede Waterproof Hiking...
Good for: Research only — consider alternatives first
Watch out for: suspicious-timing
Last analyzed: March 2026
Total Reviews
4,379
On Amazon
Verified
100%
Good
Amazon Rating
4.6
Original rating
Savinoo Rating
2.3
Adjusted rating
Our Recommendation
BE CAUTIOUS - Read individual reviews carefully, especially 1-star and 3-star reviews, before purchasing.
Analysis Summary
- MEDIUM RISK (Score: 47/100) Columbia Men's Newton Ridge Plus II Suede Waterproof Hiking... has some concerning review patterns. Major Issues Found: 82% of reviews are either 5-star or 1-star, with only 18% in between.
- Real products usually have more balanced ratings. Additional Concerns: Review dates show suspicious clustering patterns, which may indicate coordinated fake reviews. Low author diversity detected - some reviewers may have written multiple reviews. Positive Indicators: 100% of reviews are from verified purchases, which is good. 63% of reviews are detailed (over 100 words), which suggests genuine feedback..
Customer Reviews from Amazon
Most Helpful Review
"I bought the Columbia Men's Newton Ridge Plus II Suede Waterproof Hiking Boot for my husband a couple of months ago, and I have to say, we are both really impressed. He does quite a bit of hiking, and he needed something that would keep his feet dry and comfortable on those longer trails.Right out of the box, they looked great with a combination of suede and a sturdy design. He found them easy to lace up and felt like they provided good ankle support right from the start. The waterproof feature has definitely held up, even on rainy days and wet terrains, which is a huge plus.He’s also mentioned how comfortable they are for all-day wear. No blisters or sore spots, which has been a problem with other boots he’s tried in the past. The traction on the soles has performed well on both rocky paths and muddy spots, giving him confidence while hiking.Overall, these boots have been a solid choice. They look stylish enough for casual wear, but they perform when it counts on the trails. I’d definitely recommend them to anyone looking for reliable hiking boots!"
david m livingston
Great boots. Size was accurate, but I did need to reorder them in wide because…
Great boots. Size was accurate, but I did need to reorder them in wide because they are a bit tight. First time I've ever needed a wide shoe. 20 years in the Marines, I'm familiar with how a boot should fit. I've been wearing these for a few days to break them in, but honestly they felt great from day 1. Took my first hike in them today. Just a short two miles through the muddy/snowy/wet woods with my dog. Kept my feet warm and dry, traction is great, and they're very comfortable and supportive. Definitely recommend.teman
I was searching for an understated hiking boot and was delighted to find these Newtons…
I was searching for an understated hiking boot and was delighted to find these Newtons in Dark Grey/Gold Amber. They look exactly like the photos show. Although in sunlight, the grey suede reads a bit lighter. These look great and work well for both winter and summer wear. The suede is soft and compfy looking, but dark enough to hide dirt. The built quality seems to be very good. Time will tell. I love that they are lightweight, waterproof, slightly insulating, but also breathable. The soles are rugged so traction seems to be adequate for most trails. Comfort is surprisingly good. I ordered a 14W which is cut slightly large. It could even be more like a 14.5 EEE. But they don't look monsterous because the leather tops have a nice tapered shaped. The toe box is high enough to use with an aftermarket insert and thicker socks. Overall, I love these. Columbia really has a winner here.edward glospie
Reviews here are due some perspective:I am a long-time and die-hard revolving customer to the…
Reviews here are due some perspective:I am a long-time and die-hard revolving customer to the Columbia brand. I am because I have been thoroughly satisfied by their product line. There are many brands I don't return to, so if I'm continuing to purchase from the same brand, the company has won my loyalty through quality products.Having said that, I started buying Columbia hiking boots, give or take 15 years ago, despite never being a hiker. I bought them because they went well with shorts for the summer. I got used to them, and since they were lightweight and versatile, I started bringing them with me for travel. When traveling, I do a lot of urban walking. While in England, I made the mistake of wearing my Timberland Pros, walking on them over 8 miles in a day. The next day I switched to my Columbias, and it was night and day. Used them for Italy as well. I power walked on them like I had sneakers on. The major difference between these and sneakers is the ankle support. They provide significant support for ankles ( and as a tall guy with a quick gate I have rolled mine a number of times ).So you want work boots, Timberland Pros all day long, hands down. These are not work boots, nor are they serious trail hiking boots where you are going to traverse forest/jungle canopy terrain. ASOLO gets $260 for their hiking boots for a reason ( I own those too ). They feel like they are made of Kevlar. Would I wear the ASOLOs to traverse across Florence Italy? Hell no. Just like my experience in the Timberland Pro's you will come back to your hotel half broken from walking in boots not meant for the application.You have to look at the price point and application. These are excellent for daily casual use and highly recommended for urban city walking and throw in some light trails all day long. You can't beat them. Great arch support. Very comfortable and they look great. They really stand out. I bought two pairs and I'm exceedingly satisfied.For hiking I'll use my Asolo's. For work boots ( and I get knee deep in heavy construction projects) I'll use my Timberland Pro's. For everyday use with ankle support Im going with these all day. If you try to use them for what they are not designed for, you will be disappointed. Yes, they say hiking - but I'm not gonna put a $250 expectation on a $75 boot.gregor
The media could not be loaded. This is an initial review based on first day…
The media could not be loaded. This is an initial review based on first day of use. The hike started off with temperatures in the high 60s but within an hour was over 75° . I walked 4 miles on and off-road. Half of the hike was on leaf covered gravel trail while the other half was pavement.Appearance: appealing active light, trailblazer style. With an aggressive tread. Time will reveal how the suede exterior holds up. I’m concerned these boots do not have rubber surrounding/ protecting the toes against damage and tears caused by traversing rocks, and roots.Wearability: I was impressed with the fitment and comfort right out of the box, I expect comfort may improve after a break-in. The inner soul was firm but comfortable,, lacking arch support.Breathability: these boots were adequate. I didn’t notice excessive heat buildup despite the long hike and rising temperatures. They remain comfortable.Traction: I rate the souls very good too excellent. Sure footed. Firm but pliable.Value: this color was on sale! I was persuaded by the discount, but not at the cost of ignoring quality feature features.I think it’s a good choice and a good value.jason scott
This is my second pair of these for myself, and the third pair I've bought…
This is my second pair of these for myself, and the third pair I've bought (one pair was for my son). They're fantastic boots. My first pair is about 5 years old and are still suitable for banging around the yard or working in my workshop in, but they look a bit ragged ... so I ordered a new pair and they're every bit as awesome as the first pair. I wear them to work every day and I have them on now, as I write this. They have pretty good traction in snow and mud and even do ok on icy surfaces. They're super warm. I wear regular (Gold Toe) socks and my feet are toasty in these even on a day like today, where it started out at 2 degrees Fahrenheit (it has warmed up all the way to 14 degrees now ... and I just spent a bunch of time outside at work clomping around in snow and slush). They're great! Definitely get a pair if you need good, super-comfortable, water-proof fall/winter boots. They're too warm for summer, but they're excellent boots. My only "gripe" is that they've gotten more expensive over time ... but I guess everything has. And given how my first pair lasted 5 years, I can hardly complain about the price.kayla
I bought the Columbia Men's Newton Ridge Plus II Suede Waterproof Hiking Boot for my…
I bought the Columbia Men's Newton Ridge Plus II Suede Waterproof Hiking Boot for my husband a couple of months ago, and I have to say, we are both really impressed. He does quite a bit of hiking, and he needed something that would keep his feet dry and comfortable on those longer trails.Right out of the box, they looked great with a combination of suede and a sturdy design. He found them easy to lace up and felt like they provided good ankle support right from the start. The waterproof feature has definitely held up, even on rainy days and wet terrains, which is a huge plus.He’s also mentioned how comfortable they are for all-day wear. No blisters or sore spots, which has been a problem with other boots he’s tried in the past. The traction on the soles has performed well on both rocky paths and muddy spots, giving him confidence while hiking.Overall, these boots have been a solid choice. They look stylish enough for casual wear, but they perform when it counts on the trails. I’d definitely recommend them to anyone looking for reliable hiking boots!What Customers Talk About
Commonly Praised
Review Quality Analysis
Review quality helps identify authentic customer feedback. Longer, detailed reviews (50+ words) typically indicate genuine experiences, while high percentages of short reviews (under 20 words) may suggest incentivized or fake feedback.
Average Words
171
✓ Detailed reviews
Long Reviews
63%
✓ Good engagement
Short Reviews
13%
✓ Low brief reviews
Review Length Distribution
Authentic vs Brief Reviews
Average Word Count Gauge
Benchmark: 30 words = moderate, 50+ words = detailed & authentic
171
avg. words per review
Interpretation: Strong indicators of authentic, detailed customer feedback.
Review Velocity
Review velocity tracks how quickly reviews are posted. Steady, gradual accumulation is natural, while sudden spikes or bursts (20+ reviews in a single day) may indicate incentivized campaigns or coordinated activity.
Average Per Day
0.29
Natural pace
Max in One Day
5
Normal range
Steady Velocity Detected
Reviews posted at a consistent, natural pace over time — typical of organic customer feedback.
Rating Breakdown
This chart shows how customers rated Columbia Men's Newton Ridge Plus II Suede Waterproof Hiking.... Products with authentic reviews typically show a bell curve with most ratings in the 3–4 star range. A heavily polarized distribution — many 5★ and 1★ with few middle ratings — can be worth investigating further.
Key Findings
82% of reviews are either 5-star or 1-star, with only 18% in between. Real products usually have more balanced ratings.
Review dates show suspicious clustering patterns, which may indicate coordinated fake reviews.
Low author diversity detected - some reviewers may have written multiple reviews.
Warning Flags
suspicious-timing
low-author-diversity
Not sure about this product?
See alternatives on AmazonReady to buy Columbia Men's Newton Ridge Plus II Suede Waterproof Hiking...?
Our analysis is based on 4,379 reviews.
You May Also Want to Check
How does this compare?
This product scores 47/100 — below average. Review the findings carefully before buying.
Check on Amazon